Skip to content
Blog
Guides

DPC and Medicare Advantage (How MA Members Join a Direct Primary Care Practice in 2027)

Tabflows TeamNovember 16, 202614 min read

Can Medicare Advantage Members Join a Direct Primary Care Practice?

Yes. A person on a Medicare Advantage plan can join a direct primary care (DPC) practice and pay the membership themselves, the same way someone on Original Medicare can. If the DPC doctor has opted out of Medicare, the patient signs a private contract and the Advantage plan will not pay that doctor for basic Medicare benefits, while the plan keeps covering hospital care, specialists, outside labs and prescriptions under its own network rules. If the doctor is still enrolled in Medicare, the membership can only pay for services Medicare does not cover.

Hand-drawn sketch titled Seniors Still Welcome, showing a doctor greeting an older couple at the clinic door, one of them holding up a card.

This guide is for DPC physicians and owners who are deciding how to welcome patients on Medicare Advantage, and for the patients and adult children who ask them about it. It covers how each Medicare status plays out with Advantage plans, what the private contract says, and how referrals work when the DPC doctor is outside the plan's network. Our patient-facing guide to direct primary care for seniors on Medicare covers the same ground from the member's side, including what seniors pay.

This is general information, not legal, tax or insurance advice. Medicare rules are detailed and plans differ, so check your own setup with a health care attorney, and have patients check their plan's rules before they sign.

How Many Medicare Patients Are on Medicare Advantage?

More than half of them. KFF's Medicare Advantage in 2026 enrollment update reports that 55% of eligible Medicare beneficiaries, 35.2 million of the 64.2 million people with both Part A and Part B, were enrolled in Medicare Advantage in 2026. The figures use March 2026 enrollment data, and KFF published the brief on June 5, 2026 and updated it on July 1, 2026.

The same brief reports that 23% of Advantage enrollees are in a special needs plan, and that 85% of the net increase in Advantage enrollment between 2025 and 2026 came from those plans. KFF's appendix breaks Advantage penetration down by state and county, which is worth a look before you plan a senior tier, because your own area may sit well above or below the national share.

For a DPC owner, the practical point is simple. When a Medicare-age patient calls about joining, there is a good chance they are on an Advantage plan, and they will want to know how your practice fits with it before they sign anything.

How Does Each Medicare Status Work With Medicare Advantage Members?

What an Advantage member can buy from your practice depends on your Medicare status. There are three setups to compare, and the table below sums up how each one works for a patient on an Advantage plan.

Your Medicare statusCan the Advantage plan pay you for covered care?What the membership can pay forMain rule
Opted out, with private contractsNo, apart from emergency or urgent care for a patient with no private contract, and supplemental benefits a plan chooses to payYour services under the private contract42 CFR 405.425 and 422.220
Enrolled, outside the plan's networkOnly if the member's plan covers out-of-network care, which HMOs generally don't outside emergencies, and then at what Original Medicare would pay, accepted as payment in fullOnly items and services Medicare does not cover42 CFR 422.214
Enrolled, in the plan's networkYes, under your contract with the planOnly items and services Medicare does not cover, within your plan contract's terms42 CFR 422.504(g)

If you have opted out of Medicare

Opting out covers Advantage members as well as Original Medicare patients. 42 CFR 405.425(a) says that during the opt-out period, no payment may be made directly by Medicare or by any Medicare Advantage plan to the opted-out doctor, apart from the emergency and urgent care rules in 405.440. The Advantage side of that rule sits in 42 CFR 422.220, which bars an Advantage organization from paying, directly or indirectly, for basic benefits furnished by a doctor who has filed an opt-out affidavit.

That same section carves out two exceptions. An Advantage plan must pay for emergency or urgently needed services from an opted-out doctor who has not signed a private contract with the patient, and a plan may pay an opted-out doctor for services that are not basic benefits but are offered as a supplemental benefit. We found no published Advantage plan that uses the supplemental route to pay a DPC membership, so plan on the patient paying the membership themselves.

If you have not opted out yet, our step-by-step guide on how to opt out of Medicare for a DPC practice walks through the affidavit, the Medicare Administrative Contractors you file with, the two-year period and renewal.

If you are enrolled but outside the plan's network

A practice can stay enrolled in Medicare without joining any Advantage network. For an Advantage member, 42 CFR 422.214 says a provider without a contract with the plan must accept, as payment in full, the amounts it could collect if the patient were in Original Medicare, and that the statutory rules (including penalties) that apply in Original Medicare apply to that payment too.

On the Original Medicare side, Medicare.gov explains that a doctor who does not accept assignment can, in many cases, charge up to 15% above the Medicare-approved amount, which is called the limiting charge. Its concierge care page adds that a doctor who accepts assignment cannot charge extra for Medicare-covered services, so the membership fee cannot include charges for items or services Medicare usually covers, while every Medicare doctor may charge for items and services Medicare does not cover. In this setup, the membership can only buy extras. Covered visits go through the patient's plan only if it pays for care outside its network, and Medicare.gov warns HMO members that care outside the network may leave them paying the full cost.

If you are enrolled and in the plan's network

A practice that contracts with an Advantage plan agrees to that plan's payment terms. Under 42 CFR 422.504(g), every Advantage organization must make sure its contracts with providers prohibit them from holding any enrollee liable for fees that are the plan's legal obligation. Any membership fee you charge an in-network patient has to fit both the Medicare rules above and the terms of your plan contract, so read the contract with a health care attorney before you design one. Our guide to hybrid DPC with insurance and membership covers the wider trade-offs of billing insurance and charging a membership in the same practice, including survey data on how DPC physicians handle Medicare.

What Does the Private Contract Need for a Medicare Advantage Patient?

The same contract you use for everyone on Medicare. The private contract rules in 42 CFR part 405, subpart D don't have a separate version for Advantage members, and 42 CFR 405.415 lists what each contract must say. Among other things, the patient accepts responsibility for paying your charges, agrees not to submit a claim to Medicare for your services, understands that Medicare will not pay and that Medigap will not pay, and keeps the right to get Medicare-covered care from other doctors.

The contract must also state whether you are excluded from Medicare, list the start and end dates of your current two-year opt-out period, be signed by both of you, and be given to the patient before any care. A new contract is signed for each two-year period. You may also want a short, plain line saying the patient's Advantage plan will not pay for your services either, so nobody is surprised.

The emergency rule works the same way for Advantage members. A private contract can't be signed while the patient needs emergency or urgent care. If an Advantage member with no contract comes to you in that situation, 422.220(b) says the plan must pay for the emergency or urgently needed care, and our opt-out guide covers how 405.440 handles the claim.

Medicare.gov also suggests patients contact their State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) for help before signing a private contract with any doctor. Pointing patients there is a kind, low-pressure way to show you want them to understand what they are signing.

Hand-drawn sketch titled Two Paths for the Doctor, showing a doctor standing where a garden path forks toward two different clinics.

How Do Referrals Work When the DPC Doctor Is Outside the Plan's Network?

Referrals are where an Advantage plan's own rules come in. An opted-out doctor who has not been excluded from Medicare and whose enrollment was not revoked may order, certify, prescribe and refer for Medicare-covered items, services and drugs under 42 CFR 405.425(i), as long as the doctor isn't paid for those services. That rule covers what Medicare allows. Whether a particular Advantage plan accepts the referral is the plan's call.

Plan type changes the answer. Medicare.gov says HMO members generally must get care from the plan's network, apart from emergency care, out-of-area urgent care and temporary out-of-area dialysis, that most HMOs require members to choose a primary care doctor, and that in most cases a member needs a referral to see a specialist. Other plan types have their own rules, which are spelled out in each plan's Evidence of Coverage.

In practice, that leaves an Advantage member with a few questions to settle with their plan before joining:

  • Does the plan require a primary care doctor on file, and does it have to be in network?
  • Will the plan accept a referral or an order from a doctor outside its network, or does an in-network doctor need to make it?
  • Which labs and imaging centers are in network, so tests you order are covered?
  • Does the plan require prior approval for the specialists or tests the patient is most likely to need?

A member may decide to keep an in-network primary care doctor on file for plan referrals and use the DPC doctor for everyday care. If a patient chooses that, help them keep records flowing both ways, so the in-network doctor isn't making referral decisions without your notes. Our guides to getting DPC patients in to specialists and chronic disease management in DPC go deeper on coordinating with outside clinicians.

Do Medicare Advantage Plans Ever Pay Primary Care Groups a Monthly Fee?

Yes, but that is a different arrangement from a DPC membership. Advantage plans can pay contracted physician groups through capitation, which 42 CFR 422.208 defines as a set payment per patient per unit of time, usually per month, covering a specified set of services without regard to how many services are provided. The same regulation sets rules for physician incentive plans that put doctors at financial risk.

There is a category of primary care groups that contract with Advantage plans to care for their members and take a monthly payment per member from the plan. The difference from DPC is who pays and who is enrolled. In those groups the doctors are enrolled in Medicare and in the plan's network, and the plan pays them, while in a DPC practice that has opted out the patient pays you directly and the plan pays you nothing.

If a value-based contract with an Advantage plan interests you, treat it as a separate business decision from your DPC membership, with its own contract review, quality reporting and risk terms. Any payment flowing between plans, groups and referral sources also raises fraud and abuse questions, which our anti-kickback and Stark basics for DPC introduces.

What About Primary Care First and ACOs?

Neither is a route for Advantage members into a DPC. CMS's Primary Care First page says the model's final performance period ended on December 31, 2025, so it isn't an option for 2027 planning.

The Medicare Shared Savings Program holds each accountable care organization (ACO) responsible for an assigned population of Medicare fee-for-service beneficiaries, which means people in Original Medicare. Advantage members are covered by their plan instead, so they fall outside that assigned population.

What to Tell Medicare Advantage Patients Before They Join

A short, honest conversation up front saves confusion later. These are the points worth covering with every Advantage member, ideally in writing as well as in person:

  1. Your plan won't pay for the membership. Medicare doesn't cover membership fees for concierge care, which Medicare.gov says includes direct care, and if the doctor has opted out, the plan won't pay for the doctor's services either.
  2. Your plan still covers everything else. Hospital stays, specialists, outside labs and imaging stay with the plan, and so do prescriptions if the plan includes drug coverage, all under its own network and referral rules.
  3. Check referrals with your plan. Ask whether the plan needs an in-network primary care doctor on file and whether it accepts orders and referrals from the DPC doctor.
  4. You can look the doctor up. CMS publishes an opt-out affidavits look-up tool listing doctors who have opted out, with their dates.
  5. You can't add new money to an HSA once you're on Medicare. IRS Publication 969 says the contribution limit is zero starting with the first month of Medicare enrollment. Money already in a health savings account can still pay qualified expenses, and our guide to DPC and HSA rules for 2027 explains when a DPC membership counts, and a CPA can check the timing for their own situation.
  6. Read the private contract at home. Give patients time to read it with family, and point them to their SHIP if they want independent help.

If a patient asks whether to switch from an Advantage plan to Original Medicare to make DPC work, remember that it is a coverage decision with its own enrollment periods and Medigap rules, so send them to their SHIP or a licensed broker rather than advising on it yourself. Our guide to what insurance to pair with DPC covers how a membership fits alongside different kinds of coverage.

Which Medicare Setup Fits Your Practice?

There's no single right answer, and the choice reaches past Advantage members to everyone on Medicare, since 42 CFR 405.425(b) says an opted-out doctor may furnish Medicare-covered services to any Medicare beneficiary only through a private contract, apart from emergency or urgent care. A few questions help sort it out.

  • How many of your patients are or will soon be on Medicare? If your panel is mostly working-age families and employer members, the Medicare question touches fewer patients. Our break-even panel size guide helps you model the mix.
  • Do you want the membership to cover everyday care for Medicare patients? Only an opt-out lets the membership pay for services Medicare would otherwise cover.
  • Do you want to stay in Advantage networks for referrals or contracts? That points toward staying enrolled, with a membership limited to non-covered extras.
  • How will you price a senior tier? Our guide on how much to charge for a DPC membership covers age tiers, and the seniors on Medicare guide shows what practices publish for patients 65 and older.

State rules on DPC agreements apply on top of the federal Medicare rules, so check your state's DPC law in our direct primary care laws by state guide before you finalize your patient agreement.

Keeping Medicare Paperwork From Slipping

Every Advantage member who joins brings a little paperwork with them. There's a private contract to sign before the first visit and renew each two-year period, notes and referrals to send to an in-network doctor, plan-specific labs to route orders to, and records to pull back after a hospital stay. None of it is hard on its own, but it lives across your EHR, your billing tool, your phone and fax inbox, and the patient's plan, and that's where things fall through.

Tabflows is a dedicated tech team that connects the tools a clinic already uses, like the EHR, membership billing and patient messaging, so the follow-ups between them get done. For a practice with Advantage members, that can mean a drafted follow-up task, like sending notes to the patient's in-network doctor, with an owner and a due date for your team to check and save when someone opens the chart, and the patient's context from every connected system when their plan calls.

The Bottom Line

Medicare Advantage members can join a DPC, and with more than half of eligible Medicare beneficiaries now in Advantage plans, the question will come up at your front desk. If you have opted out, they sign the same private contract as any Medicare patient, pay the membership themselves, and keep their plan for everything outside your practice. If you are still enrolled, the membership can only pay for what Medicare doesn't cover.

The details that matter most are the plan's referral and network rules, so help each patient check them before they join. Then keep the contract, the referrals and the records moving, and Advantage members can get the same unhurried primary care as everyone else on your panel.

FAQs

Can someone on a Medicare Advantage plan join a direct primary care practice?

Yes. A Medicare Advantage member can join a direct primary care (DPC) practice and pay the membership themselves. If the DPC doctor has opted out of Medicare, the patient signs the same private contract an Original Medicare patient signs, and the Advantage plan will not pay that doctor for basic Medicare benefits under 42 CFR 422.220. The plan keeps covering the patient's other care, such as hospital stays, specialists, outside labs and prescriptions, under its own network and referral rules.

Will a Medicare Advantage plan pay for a DPC membership?

Generally no. Medicare.gov says Medicare does not cover membership fees for concierge care, a category it says includes direct care. For opted-out doctors, 42 CFR 422.220 bars Advantage plans from paying for basic benefits, with two exceptions. A plan must pay for emergency or urgently needed care from an opted-out doctor who has no private contract with the patient, and a plan may pay an opted-out doctor for supplemental benefits it chooses to offer. We found no published plan that uses that second option to pay a DPC membership.

Do I need a different private contract for Medicare Advantage patients?

No separate Advantage version exists in the rules. The private contract requirements in 42 CFR 405.415 apply to every Medicare beneficiary, and 42 CFR 405.425 says that during an opt-out period no payment may be made by Medicare or by any Medicare Advantage plan to the opted-out doctor. A patient in an Advantage plan signs the same contract, before care, for each two-year opt-out period.

Can an opted-out DPC doctor make referrals for a Medicare Advantage patient?

An opted-out doctor who is not excluded and whose enrollment was not revoked may order, prescribe and refer for Medicare-covered items and services under 42 CFR 405.425(i). Whether the Advantage plan accepts that referral is a plan rule. Medicare.gov says most HMO members need to choose a primary care doctor and usually need a referral to see a specialist, so the patient should ask the plan how referrals work when their main doctor is outside the network.

What share of Medicare patients are in Medicare Advantage?

KFF reports that 55% of eligible Medicare beneficiaries, 35.2 million of the 64.2 million people with both Part A and Part B, were enrolled in Medicare Advantage in 2026, based on March 2026 enrollment data. KFF's brief also has figures by state and county.

Can a DPC doctor stay enrolled in Medicare and still charge Advantage members a membership?

Only for things Medicare does not cover. Medicare.gov says a doctor who accepts assignment cannot charge extra for Medicare-covered services, so a membership cannot include charges for items or services Medicare usually covers. A doctor in the plan's network is also bound by the hold-harmless terms 42 CFR 422.504(g) requires in plan contracts, and a doctor outside the network must accept what Original Medicare would pay as payment in full under 42 CFR 422.214. Talk with a health care attorney before designing a fee for this setup.