Is One Medical making direct primary care obsolete?
No. Direct primary care is defined by how it is paid for and by a small panel for each doctor, and a large company entering primary care doesn't change that model or the reasons patients choose it. In direct primary care, the membership fee is the practice's pay for primary care, the practice doesn't bill insurance for those visits, and each doctor keeps a small panel so patients reach the same doctor directly. Any membership, from a national brand like Amazon's One Medical or a local clinic, is DPC only if it works that way, and the honest way to compare them is to ask each one the same handful of questions.

The question comes up every time a large company announces a new health benefit. Physicians thinking about opening a DPC wonder whether they will be competing with a national brand, and owners wonder whether their members will drift away. This guide answers it from primary sources on how DPC works, not from claims about any one company's product.
We don't describe One Medical, Amazon's health benefits or any other big-company membership here. Their plans, prices and rules change, and the only reliable source is each company's own current terms on its own website. What we can do is explain what makes DPC what it is, and give you the questions that sort any membership into the right bucket.
What makes direct primary care different from other memberships?
The AAFP describes direct primary care as "a meaningful alternative to fee-for-service (FFS) insurance billing", typically charging patients a monthly, quarterly or annual fee that covers all or most primary care services. That includes clinical and laboratory services, consultative services, care coordination and comprehensive care management.
In the AAFP's side-by-side of DPC and concierge medicine on the same page, DPC practices "rely solely on patient fees, not accepting insurance or participating in government programs," while concierge practices "may continue to accept insurance plans and government programs and bill patient's insurance company for covered services." That one line is the cleanest way to sort any membership you are looking at, whatever the size of the company behind it.
Four features hold the model together:
- No insurance billing for primary care. The fee pays for the care, so the practice doesn't code visits or wait on claims, and members don't get a bill or an explanation of benefits for an office visit.
- A flat, predictable fee. Members pay the same amount whether they come in once a year or every week.
- A small panel. Because the practice isn't paid per visit, each doctor can care for fewer patients and give each one more time.
- Direct access to the same doctor. Members text, call or message their own physician or a small team that knows them.
The AAFP and DPC Alliance 2026 Direct Primary Care Data Brief, which reports 2025 practice data, shows how closely real practices follow that shape. Among respondents practicing in a DPC setting, 94% had no per-visit charges, only 8% capped the number of visits the membership covers, and a small subset of 9% still incorporated some fee-for-service billing.
For a fuller patient-facing explanation, our guide to what direct primary care is walks through what is usually included and what isn't.
Does a membership that bills insurance count as DPC?
Not under the federal definition that now matters most to patients with HSAs. Public Law 119-21 added a direct primary care service arrangement to the tax code, and IRS Notice 2026-5 explains it. The arrangement has to provide care "consisting solely of primary care services provided by primary care practitioners," and "the sole compensation for such care is a fixed periodic fee."
The notice then answers the exact question this post is about. In its Q-11 and A-11, the IRS says an arrangement that provides care to members who have paid a fixed periodic fee, "but bills separately for those items and services (through insurance or otherwise)," is not a direct primary care service arrangement. In other words, a fee plus insurance-billed visits is a different thing in the eyes of the IRS.
The notice also draws a fair line for practices. Its A-12 says a qualifying arrangement can still offer services outside the membership and bill both members and non-members for them, as long as those services aren't tied to membership. So a DPC can sell an extra service separately, but it can't charge the fee and then bill insurance for the care the fee covers.
This matters for patients with HSAs because, under the new rule, only a qualifying arrangement whose fees stay within a monthly cap lets them keep contributing. Our DPC HSA rules for 2027 cover the cap, what's excluded and what practices should put in their member agreements. If someone asks whether a big-company membership works with their HSA, the safest answer is to check that company's current terms and ask its team directly.
Why a small DPC panel is hard to replace
A DPC practice competes on a small panel and one doctor who knows you, so panel size and continuity are the things worth asking any membership about.
The AAFP and DPC Alliance data brief puts numbers on it for 2025 (the panel and e-visit figures cover all respondents, about half of them in DPC):
- The average patient panel across all respondents was 504 patients, up from 402 in 2024.
- Among respondents practicing in DPC, 69% ran a single physician panel.
- 54% reported an average in-office appointment longer than 30 minutes, and only 4% reported an average under 15 minutes.
- Respondents averaged 13 e-visit encounters a week, up from 11 in 2024 and 7 in 2022, counting virtual visits and telemedicine.
None of that tells you anything about any other company, and it isn't meant to. It tells you what to ask about. If a membership can't tell you how many patients each clinician cares for, or whether you'll see the same person next time, you have learned something important about the model it runs.
The same brief also shows the model isn't standing still. Pure DPC remained the dominant practice type at 71% of respondents in DPC, down from 90% in 2022 and 84% in 2024, which the brief reads as growing use of hybrid and concierge models. So the line between "membership" and "DPC" is blurring inside DPC itself, which is one more reason to ask questions rather than go by labels.
Is DPC still worth starting with big companies in the market?
The physicians in DPC say the model is worth it for reasons a national brand doesn't change. In the 2026 data brief, respondents practicing in DPC reported improvement in care quality and patient relationships (99%), work-life balance (89%) and paperwork burden (86%). Only 17% said income was a driver for choosing the model.
The brief is just as honest about the hard parts. The top challenges for respondents in DPC were patient panel growth (40%), nonvisit care burden (33%) and revenue stability (29%), and 47% reported lower earnings in DPC practice, while 30% reported higher earnings. Competition for patients' attention is real, from big companies and from everyone else, and panel growth is where it shows up.
That's why the useful question for a physician isn't whether a large company will make DPC obsolete. It's whether the patients and employers in your area want what a small, flat-fee practice offers, and whether they can find you. Our posts on whether direct primary care is worth it and choosing between DPC and an insurance-based practice go through that decision with local data. The brief also found that, on average, 80% of respondents' patients had private health insurance, which fits the AAFP's note that DPC practices often suggest patients keep a high-deductible, wrap-around policy to cover emergencies.

Questions to ask any primary care membership
Whether you're a patient choosing a plan, an employer comparing benefits or a physician explaining your practice, these six questions sort any membership quickly. They work the same for a national brand, a hospital program, a concierge practice and an independent DPC, and the answers come from the company's own current terms or from a conversation with its team.
| Question to ask | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Does the membership bill my insurance for visits? | If it does, you may owe copays or deductibles on top of the fee, and it likely isn't a DPC arrangement for HSA purposes. |
| How many patients does each clinician care for? | Panel size decides how quickly you get an appointment and how much time you get once you're in the room. |
| Will I see the same doctor every time? | Continuity is the reason many people join a membership. A rotating roster can be convenient but is a different kind of care. |
| Who reads my messages, and how fast do they answer? | "Direct access" can mean your own doctor, a small team that knows you or a central pool. Ask for the expected response time in writing. |
| What does the fee include, and what costs extra? | Visits, labs, in-office procedures and medications can be included, discounted or billed separately. Get the list before you sign. |
| How do I cancel, and is there a fee to leave or rejoin? | Contract length, notice periods and re-enrollment fees vary widely, and they matter most when your plans change. |
Our longer checklist of questions to ask before joining a DPC adds lab and medication prices, records, Medicare and what to look for at a meet and greet.
What should an employer ask before choosing a membership?
Employers are a big part of DPC, so the question lands on HR desks too. In the data brief, 55% of respondents practicing in DPC had employer-based contracts, and most of those practices worked with small employers, with 69% working with employers under 10 employees and 59% with employers of 10 to 25.
An employer comparing a national membership with a local DPC can use the same six questions, plus a few of its own:
- What does the employer pay, and what will employees still pay at visits?
- Will claims still flow to the health plan for primary care visits, or does the fee cover them?
- What reporting does the employer get, and does it include visit counts or quality measures?
- Can the employer end the contract, and what happens to employees' care if it does?
The brief found that among DPC practices with employer contracts, 26% contracted with employers that asked for data, and 95% of those requests focused on visit counts. If reporting matters to you, say so up front. For physicians, our guide to selling direct primary care to employers covers how to present a flat-fee contract clearly.
How health systems and big companies fit in
Large organizations offering memberships aren't new. Our guide to how health systems launch direct primary care walks through the models larger organizations use, from true DPC programs to hybrid memberships that stay in-network, and why the HSA rule treats them differently.
For a physician, that landscape is useful context rather than a threat. A patient who has tried a membership that bills insurance and wants a different experience can be exactly the person who joins a DPC. The difference between models, explained plainly, is part of how you describe your own practice. Our comparison of DPC and concierge medicine shows how to explain the billing difference in a sentence or two.
How patients find a DPC instead
Patients who want a small panel and a doctor who answers their texts need a way to find one. Our DPC Finder lists direct primary care and concierge practices by state and dates every fact it shows, so a patient can compare what local practices publish without guessing. Physicians can check that their own listing is current.
Our guide to how patients find a DPC in 2027 covers the search terms, directories and referrals that actually bring members in. When a national brand is in the headlines, those are the places a curious patient looks next, and a clear listing with honest answers to the six questions above is the best response a practice can give.
The work behind direct access
The promise that sets DPC apart, a doctor who knows you and answers quickly, depends on a lot of work happening between tools. Messages come in through the phone system, labs land in the EHR, refills and follow-ups need someone to own them, and membership billing lives somewhere else again. In a small practice, that work tends to fall on the physician late in the evening.
Tabflows is a dedicated tech team that connects the tools a clinic already uses, the EHR, billing and messaging, so follow-ups, tasks and patient context sit in one place. It isn't an EHR or a membership platform, and it doesn't replace either.
The bottom line
Big-company memberships and direct primary care can share the word "membership" and still be different models. DPC is defined by a fee that pays for primary care without insurance billing, a small panel and direct access to the same doctor, and the IRS now draws the same billing line for HSA purposes. Large companies entering primary care don't change what DPC offers, and the physicians running DPC practices report gains in care quality and patient relationships that a brand name doesn't erase.
For patients and employers, the fair way to choose is to ask every option the same six questions and check each company's current terms on its own website. For physicians, the best answer to the headlines is a clear explanation of your model and a listing patients can find.
FAQs
Is One Medical the same thing as direct primary care?
Only if it works the way direct primary care does. Direct primary care is defined by how it is paid for. The membership fee is the practice's pay for primary care, the practice does not bill insurance for those visits, and patients see the same small team every time. Any membership, from a big company or a local clinic, is DPC only if it works that way. Check each company's current terms on its own website and ask whether visits are billed to your insurance.
Will big-company memberships make independent DPC practices obsolete?
The data DPC physicians report doesn't measure competition from big companies, and it doesn't show DPC fading. In the AAFP and DPC Alliance 2026 data brief, most physicians practicing in DPC report better care quality and patient relationships, and the average panel across all respondents was 504 in 2025, up from 402 in 2024. Any membership that bills insurance for visits is a different model from DPC, so check each option's own current terms rather than assuming one replaces the other.
What should I ask before joining any primary care membership?
Ask whether visits are billed to your insurance, how many patients each clinician cares for, whether you see the same doctor every time, who reads your messages and how fast they answer, what the fee includes and what costs extra, and how cancellation works. The same questions work for a big-company membership, a concierge practice and a DPC practice.
Can I use my HSA for a membership that bills my insurance?
Generally not under the new direct primary care rule. IRS Notice 2026-5 says a direct primary care service arrangement must have the fixed periodic fee as its sole compensation, so an arrangement that charges a membership fee and also bills separately for the included care, through insurance or otherwise, does not qualify. Our DPC HSA guide explains the full rule and the monthly cap.
Should an employer pick a national membership or a local DPC practice?
It depends on what the employer wants to fix. If the goal is a named doctor who knows each employee, fast access without claims and a flat predictable cost, a local DPC contract is built for that. Whatever the choice, ask every option the same questions about insurance billing, panel size, continuity, messaging, what is included and how to end the contract.
How do I find a direct primary care practice near me?
Our DPC Finder lists DPC practices by state and dates the facts it shows, including membership prices where a practice publishes them. Book a meet and greet with one or two practices and bring your questions about access, what is included and how the membership works with your insurance.